A year of consumer outrage and federal court action has knocked Woolworths and Coles down by over $4 billion in brand value, exposing the fragility of customer trust. Small businesses can learn a lot from the supermarket giants’ brand crisis, from reputation management to the importance of transparency and legal compliance.
2024 was a tough year for Australia’s supermarket giants, Woolworths and Coles. Their image took a major hit after allegations of price gouging and misleading pricing tactics sparked a wave of consumer outrage. The public outcry wasn’t just noise—it translated into real consequences, with a staggering 46% of Australians saying they would shop at these supermarkets less due to the controversy. For SMEs, this story is packed with lessons on the importance of trust, reputation, and customer loyalty.
The crisis started when both Woolworths and Coles faced federal court action from the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC). The watchdog accused them of inflating product prices by at least 15%, only to later promote these inflated prices as part of their ongoing discount campaigns. The allegations led to a sharp decline in their brand value—down a combined $4.1 billion in just one year, a 31% drop. Woolworths’ brand value fell from $15.4 billion to $12.7 billion, while Coles dropped from $9.8 billion to $8.4 billion.
Despite the controversy, the supermarkets remained at the top of the food chain, with Woolworths still holding the second spot and Coles coming in fifth in terms of brand value. This might seem like a victory at first glance, but it comes with a warning. Brand Finance Australia’s managing director, Mark Crowe, explained that the drop in brand value didn’t immediately affect the checkout process. Location and market share are still the major drivers for consumer choice. But here’s the catch—if Woolworths and Coles don’t act quickly to repair their reputations, this backlash could eventually hit their bottom line hard.
So, what lessons can small businesses take away from this brand crisis?
Customer trust is everything
Example: Woolworths and Coles’ price gouging scandal
The negative publicity surrounding Woolworths and Coles wasn’t just about high prices; it was about customers feeling misled by inflated prices. A survey revealed that nearly half of Australians said they would shop at these supermarkets less because of the allegations.
For SMEs, maintaining customer trust is crucial. Small businesses should focus on being transparent with pricing, offering clear communication, and always prioritizing customer satisfaction.
A good example comes from Harris Farm Markets, a company focusing on transparency and building trust with their customers. The Australian supermarket chain is known for providing clear and honest communication about their pricing and sourcing. Harris Farm Markets often publishes detailed information on where their produce comes from and how it is sourced, making customers feel more confident in their purchasing decisions.
Reputation management matters
Example: Woolworths’ PR crisis
Woolworths’ reputation took a massive hit when accusations of misleading pricing were brought to light, severely affecting customer confidence. Small businesses should stay on top of their reputation. This means actively managing customer reviews and responding to negative feedback.
Muffin Break, for instance, uses social media not just to promote new products but to quickly address any concerns customers have, helping them avoid potential PR disasters and show their commitment to service.
The power of social media
Example: Consumer backlash on social media
In the wake of the pricing scandals, social media became the battleground where Woolworths and Coles faced the wrath of angry consumers. Complaints flooded platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok.
SMEs can learn from this by using social media not just for promotions but also for engagement.
Don’t rely on one market or product
Example: Woolworths’ New Zealand struggles
Woolworths faced major losses in New Zealand, highlighting the risk of putting all your eggs in one basket. When the company was forced to impair its New Zealand supermarkets, it impacted its overall profits.
For SMEs, diversifying is key.
Legal compliance is non-negotiable
Example: ACCC Investigation Against Woolworths and Coles
The legal fallout from Woolworths and Coles’ price-fixing accusations serves as a stark reminder of the importance of staying on top of consumer laws. SMEs must make sure that their business practices comply with relevant regulations.
Location isn’t enough
Example: The convenience vs. brand reputation battle
Woolworths and Coles might dominate the market, but customer loyalty was weakened because they relied too much on the convenience of their physical locations.
SMEs need to offer more than just proximity.
Leverage data to drive success
Example: Woolworths’ Use of Algorithms
Woolworths and Coles used data-driven strategies to target customers, but their misuse of trust led to negative consequences.
SMEs can take advantage of data to personalize experiences, but only if used ethically.
Build meaningful relationships
Example: The Fall of Woolworths and Coles’ Emotional Connection
Woolworths and Coles were known for their convenience and competitive prices, but they lacked the emotional connection that could have kept customers loyal during the price hike scandal.
For SMEs, creating deeper customer relationships is key.
Keep up to date with our stories on LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook and Instagram.
