The hidden cost of chasing a quick sales spike

Big sales days mostly attract existing customers buying at a discount, not new ones, warns Klaviyo's Brian Kealey.

News · 17 Sept 2026 · 2 min read
Above The hidden cost of chasing a quick sales spike. Dynamic Business

With Vogue Online Shopping Night just around the corner, retailers are bracing for a surge in sales. However, new research from marketing platform Klaviyo warns that relying heavily on steep discounts to drive short-term gains may ultimately have a negative impact in the long run.

Brian Kealey, Klaviyo's VP and MD APJ, says the appeal of a big discount day is obvious but often misleading. "Shopping moments like Vogue Online Shopping Night tempt retailers to offer discounts for a quick sales peak, but deep discounting is a short-term fix that threatens long-term growth."

The post-sale hangover

According to Kealey, heavy discount days tend to attract existing customers rather than new ones. "Instead of bringing in new audiences, heavy sales days mostly drive existing loyal customers to buy core inventory at a bargain. This jeopardises future demand and leaves brands nursing a post-sale hangover."

Kealey points to Klaviyo's own research, produced with James Hurman, which found brands that run deep discounts see revenue drop by an average of 27% in the two to four weeks following a major discount period. "Even worse, data shows deep discounters actually grow 50% slower than full-price retailers across every price point. Slashing margins simply doesn't scale a business."

A measured way off the discount treadmill

Kealey isn't arguing retailers should abandon discounting altogether, he says stopping abruptly isn't the answer either. Instead, he recommends gradually tapering off big event discounts in favour of more targeted, value-add incentives. "Turning off the tap overnight isn't the answer either. Brands need a measured approach... gradually tapering off deep event discounts in favour of targeted, value-add incentives that protect both brand reputation and profit margins would be the solution."

His overall message to retailers eyeing next week's sales event is to think beyond the immediate spike. "Ultimately, relying on mass sales events to chase quick revenue is a trap. Sustainable growth belongs to the retailers that step off the discount treadmill and focus on preserving full-price value."

Note: figures cited are from Klaviyo's own proprietary research and have not been independently verified.

Yajush Gupta
Yajush Gupta is the Editorial Lead and a business journalist for Dynamic Business, an Australian media platform focused on small and medium enterprises (SMEs) and startups.
From the floor
Closer to this story than we are?
If you're building in this space — or watching it reshape your market — pitch us. We edit it; you get the byline.
More from the desk

Keep reading.

News ◆

A simple checklist for catching AI slop before it reaches your customers

More than a quarter of businesses admit AI-generated work goes to customers unchecked. A simple review process can close that gap.

Yajush Gupta · 2 min
Funding | Investment ◆

Australian startups raise from Series C to seed across five sectors

Quantum software, stroke robotics, cattle feed, insolvency AI and office drink dispensers: here are five Australian companies that announced funding this week. Q-CTRL raised US$290 million in a Ser…

Yajush Gupta · 2 min
News ◆

How Brisbane’s Lock Jaw beat European copycats and won a national export award

Exports drive two-thirds of the Brisbane manufacturer’s sales, but overseas growth brought imitators. Co-founder Craig Charlton shares why defending their design proved just as critical as inventing it.

Yajush Gupta · 2 min
0 people like this

Comments

Loading comments…