In a world where shoppers can get groceries delivered in an hour, loyalty is fleeting. For specialty grocers, that’s a real threat – and a real opportunity. To thrive, they must offer more than just great products. They need to build emotional stickiness.
That’s exactly what Wild Fork Foods has done. A Rapid Grocery POS customer, Wild Fork started as a single storefront and has grown into a 60-store powerhouse. But it’s not just smart merchandising or sleek packaging driving their expansion. It’s their bold rethink of customer loyalty – using data, tech, and personalized experiences to create lasting relationships.
Here’s what Wild Fork is doing right – and what other grocers should borrow from their playbook.
From frozen cuts to fan favorites
Wild Fork launched with a focused mission: deliver premium, flash-frozen meat and seafood without the middleman markup. Their vertically integrated model ensures peak freshness, high quality, and competitive prices.
But what really accelerated their growth wasn’t just what they sold – it was how they sold it. Loyalty wasn’t tacked on later. It was baked into the brand strategy from the beginning.
Loyalty that feels like a relationship
Most grocery programs rely on tired punch cards and minimal discounts. Wild Fork took a different approach. They built a dynamic, data-powered loyalty engine that adapts to each shopper.
They use platforms like bLoyal – integrated with Rapid’s built-in loyalty programs – to create 360-degree customer profiles. These track purchase behavior, preferred fulfillment methods, click behavior, and even cart abandonment patterns. The result? Hyper-personalized offers that speak directly to each customer’s habits and tastes.
- Regular buyer of premium cuts? You might get a “dry-aged sampler” promo.
- Haven’t visited in a while? Expect a reactivation email with a relevant discount.
It’s less about chasing transactions – and more about sustaining a relationship.
Tiered rewards that drive engagement
Wild Fork’s loyalty program introduces gamification with real value. Rather than a flat 5% back, they use a tiered model that rewards frequency and spend with increasingly exclusive benefits:
- Base Tier: Cashback in points, basic offers
- Mid Tier: Free shipping, early product access, invites to tasting events
- Top Tier: Surprise boxes, concierge-level support, VIP bundle pricing
A live progress bar in the app fuels motivation. The psychology is simple: people don’t just want discounts – they want to feel seen, special, and appreciated.
Seamless omnichannel loyalty
Consistency is key. Wild Fork ensures that a shopper’s identity – and perks – follow them everywhere: in-store, online, curbside, or app.
At checkout, scanning a QR code loads your preferences instantly. Smart prompts surface custom offers, and staff are alerted to any special requests. Some stores are even piloting camera-linked self-checkout for instant recognition – frictionless, secure, and personalized.
Loyalty isn’t a separate system. It’s the thread connecting every Wild Fork touchpoint.
Transparency builds trust
Wild Fork knows that loyalty is a two-way street. They’re upfront about how they use customer data and give shoppers control over what’s tracked and how they’re contacted. That builds confidence – and deepens engagement.
Their customer service seals the deal. Social platforms are full of stories about fast refunds, proactive outreach, and thoughtful gestures when something goes wrong. In a time of automated indifference, that’s a huge differentiator.
What other grocers can steal
If you’re a specialty grocer, Wild Fork’s playbook isn’t just aspirational – it’s actionable. Here’s how to start:
- Use data as a relationship tool. Don’t just collect it – translate it into value your customers can feel.
- Build rewards that evolve. Tiers and milestones make spending feel purposeful, not routine.
- Make loyalty omnipresent. Your digital and physical channels should be extensions of the same identity.
- Be radically transparent. Treat customer data with care and give users meaningful control.
- Surprise and delight. Loyalty isn’t just about saving money – it’s about emotional connection.
The takeaway
Wild Fork proves that when loyalty is more than a marketing tactic – when it’s a philosophy – it drives real growth. For specialty grocers facing fierce competition and rising costs, this kind of experience-driven strategy isn’t just nice to have. It’s the future.
Smart loyalty isn’t about gimmicks. It’s about building trust, adding value, and showing up for your customers – again and again.
two, they’ve grown into a major player with 60 locations—and they’re not slowing down, with plans to add more stores soon.
So, what’s their secret? A big part of it is how they’ve rethought customer loyalty. WFF isn’t just handing out points and calling it a day. They’ve built a loyalty program that’s smart, flexible, and focused on giving people a better experience every time they shop. Whether online or in-store, WFF has figured out how to make loyalty feel personal and rewarding.
Let’s take a closer look at what they’re doing right—and what other specialty grocers can learn from it.
Read also: Let’s Talk: What does it take to deliver world-class customer service?
From one store to a national footprint
Wild Fork started with a pretty simple idea: give people better access to high-quality, flash-frozen meat and seafood. By cutting out the middleman and freezing products at peak freshness, they could offer premium options at prices people could actually afford.
The model caught on fast. Word of mouth, great product quality, and a smart business strategy helped them grow. Now, they’re expanding into even more markets, with dozens of new stores on the way.
But the physical expansion only tells part of the story. What really helped WFF scale effectively was their focus on loyalty and customer experience.
Using technology to make shopping personal
Wild Fork’s approach to loyalty isn’t about one-size-fits-all discounts. Instead, they use tools like bLoyal and other data platforms to really get to know their customers. Everything—from what you buy and how often you shop, to whether you prefer delivery or pickup—helps WFF shape a more personalized experience.
For example, if you’re a regular steak buyer, you might get a special offer on dry-aged cuts or a “surf and turf” bundle that pairs beef with shrimp. If you haven’t shopped in a while, you might get a reminder with a personalized promo to come back.
They also track how customers shop on their website, what they click on, and what they leave in their carts. With that information, they can tweak their homepage for each shopper or send just the right follow-up emails.
All of this makes customers feel seen—and it gives them a good reason to keep coming back.
A loyalty program that actually feels rewarding
A lot of grocery loyalty programs feel stale. You collect points, maybe get a $5 coupon every once in a while, and that’s it. WFF wanted to do something more engaging. So, they built a tiered rewards system that grows with each shopper’s engagement.
Here’s a quick breakdown of how it works:
- Entry-level shoppers get a basic reward structure, like 5% back in points and access to occasional deals.
- Mid-level members unlock free shipping, invites to tasting events, and early access to new products.
- Top-tier members get the VIP treatment: quarterly surprise boxes, special pricing on bundles, and even direct support for specialty orders.
The tiers are tracked visually in the app, so people can see their progress and what they’re working toward. That little “almost there!” bar is surprisingly motivating—and Wild Fork has seen many customers increase their spending just to unlock the next level of perks.
Bringing that same experience in-store
One of the most impressive things about WFF is how they’ve blended the online and in-store experiences. At checkout, a quick scan of a QR code on your phone pulls up your loyalty profile. It applies discounts, shows personalized suggestions, and even alerts staff if you’ve got a special request in your account (like asking for wagyu trimmings again).
They’re even experimenting with camera recognition technology that links your loyalty account automatically when you scan in at self-checkout. It’s discreet, quick, and helps personalize the experience even further without adding any hassle.
All of this makes shopping feel smoother, faster, and more tailored to the individual.
Consistent experience, no matter how you shop
Today’s shoppers don’t stick to just one method of buying groceries—they jump between in-store visits, online orders, delivery apps, and curbside pickup. Wild Fork gets this, and they’ve built their loyalty program to keep up.
Whether you’re browsing their website, using the app, or walking into a physical store, your profile, rewards, and order history follow you. That means your points stay in one place, your preferences are always remembered, and you get consistent treatment across all channels.
This seamless connection across platforms helps build trust and makes it easy for customers to stay loyal, no matter how they prefer to shop.
Customers first: Trust, transparency, and service
None of this would work if WFF didn’t put trust at the center of their strategy. They’re transparent about how they collect and use customer data, and they give people full control over their preferences and communications. If you don’t want to get texts or emails, you can easily opt out. If you want to adjust your profile or see what data’s being tracked, it’s all there for you.
They also shine when it comes to customer service. Even on platforms like Reddit, shoppers have shared positive stories about how quickly WFF fixed issues or sent out replacements for damaged orders. That kind of follow-through matters more than most brands realize.
What other grocers can learn
Wild Fork has created a loyalty experience that goes beyond discounts—it’s about building relationships, making shopping more enjoyable, and helping customers feel valued. Here are a few things other specialty grocers can take from their playbook:
- Use data to make it personal. Even small bits of insight—like favorite products or order frequency—can help tailor promotions and keep customers engaged.
- Make loyalty easy. Don’t overcomplicate the rewards. Focus on benefits that people actually care about, and make it simple to redeem them.
- Connect the dots. Whether someone’s online, in the app, or at the store, make sure their experience feels connected.
- Keep it fresh. A good loyalty program should evolve. Add new perks, highlight seasonal favorites, and celebrate customers as they level up.
- Be transparent. People are more willing to share their data when they know how it’s used and when they feel in control of it.
Wrapping up
Wild Fork proves that when loyalty is more than a marketing tactic – when it’s a philosophy – it drives real growth. For specialty grocers facing fierce competition and rising costs, this kind of experience-driven strategy isn’t just nice to have. It’s the future.Smart loyalty isn’t about gimmicks. It’s about building trust, adding value, and showing up for your customers – again and again. Rapid POS can help your store achieve the same benefits, click here to reach out today!
Keep up to date with our stories on LinkedIn, Twitter, Facebook and Instagram.
